A Florida man allegedly shot his ex-fiancée in the head after she called off their engagement.
Timothy Hyder, 57, then allegedly asked the victim’s daughter to call 911.
Hyder was charged with first-degree murder in connection with the death of 58-year-old Natalie “Dawn” Du’Mee.
Hyder, in an interview with police, alleged he and Du’Mee were at a football watch party when they started to argue and Du’Mee told him she didn’t want to marry him, according to an arrest warrant affidavit obtained by PEOPLE.
Hyder told police that the couple continued to argue when they returned home and Natalie “reiterated that she was not going to marry him and gave him the engagement ring back,” per the affidavit.
Hyder then went inside and grabbed his .357 revolver and went outside to the back porch where Du’Mee was sitting. He allegedly then asked Du’Mee if “she was sure that she was …